The Anarchy of Thought

Charity begins at home. Perhaps. But then so does the long revolution against the Establishment.

Saturday, March 12, 2005

Just A Housewife

Anjana is now sitting down on the silent verandah in the cool afternoon breeze...She has had a long and busy day today...She woke up at 5 am at the crack of dawn, lit the stove, and cooked breakfast for her husband and her two daughters...Food was ready on the table by 7 am, and everyone wolved it down and rushed out...There was a sudden calm in the house immediately, and Anjana sat down for a while in the living room silently staring at the strange figures on the embroidered curtains...And then it was time to get back to work...She spent the morning washing the clothes, removing the cobwebs, mopping the bathroom, sweeping the floors, dusting the carpets, and cleaning the utensils...Time flew, and soon it was close to afternoon...She rushed into the kitchen and started making food for the family again...Now it is all over, and she is enjoying a few quiet moments of rest on the verandah...Her daughter Niranjana comes home and asks her, 'Mother, can't you get a proper job? Perhaps in some office?'
'What do you mean? Don't I have one already, feeding and taking care of this family?'
'You see, I need to fill in this application form, and there is this place where I need to write what my parents do. I feel ashamed to say that you are just a housewife. Can't you get a real job like other women?'
Anjana looks at the setting sun slowly going down into the tired hills...The truth begins to sink into her...Yes, she is just a housewife...
The Biography Of The Transparent Ironist

The ship-wrecked Ironist would live on that island for another five years. Every evening, the islanders would gather round the fire to tell their stories of forgotten times, and the Ironist too would sit down beside them listening to them, gently nodding his head to the sharp sounds of the crackling twigs. Sometimes it was his turn to tell them a story, and his listeners always had a sense of uncanniness whenever they heard his stories, a sense which, however, they could not quite put into words. One morning, they found the Ironist dead in his brown cottage by the sea-shore, and under his table also a thick dusty sheaf of yellowed papers. Some of the islanders collected them into a book which they published as his autobiography. It was only then that they were finally able to explain precisely what it was about his stories that used to unnerve them. The Ironist had delicately merged their stories into the narrative of his own life, sometimes leaving gaps that they could complete with their details, and sometimes filling them in with his own strange tales. On reading his autobiography, they were in fact unable to say where their stories had ended and where his had started. They felt that they were being invited to enter into one gigantic inter-connected web into which he had masterfully woven the stories of the islanders and his own story to form one seamless whole. Somehow they were reading their own biographies through his autobiography : in it was reflected some of their most deeply-cherished views, was expressed some of their hidden wishes, and was voiced some of their unspoken griefs.

Friday, March 11, 2005

A Morning's Tale

The alarm clock goes off at 6:45 am, and shakes Miranda out of her restless sleep...She scampers out of bed and desperately tries to find the clock...Within half an hour, Susannah and Dominic are woken up, dressed in their bright school-dresses and shining black shoes, and are eating their cereal with hot milk...Amazingly, they are not making any fuss today and are gulping down their food with no complaints...At 7:30 am, they are ready to go to school in Miranda's new Mazda...The children are dropped off, and Miranda drives towards the City at full throttle, and when she approaches her office swerves into the parking space...She gets out from the car, and waits at the intersection for the lights to turn green...
As she watches the cars fleeting past her, the world suddenly seems to have frozen to a stand-still...For a long moment that seems like an eternity to her, everything becomes immobile...She feels that she is in some dream, and tries to force herself out of it, but to no avail...She feels like screaming out but she cannot even part her lips to squeeze the cry through them...The people on the pavement, the clouds in the sky above, and the cars in the street in front of her have now all grinded to an abrupt halt...It is one terrible never-ending moment...
And then, someone pats Miranda on the back : 'Hi Miranda, ready for another day?...Are you all right? You look like you have seen a ghost!'
Miranda finds it hard to believe that she has finally come back to this world. She splutters : 'Oh yes, I am prepared for another day.'
Miranda and Julianne enter the office. It is time to get ready for yet another one of those days.
An Appeal From My Nigerian Friend

Dear Mr Ironist,

I write to you in great distress. I came to the UK from Nigeria with my parents as a young boy of 6, and I have been living here since then. I was never very religious during my growing-up years, and though I remember having gone to church on two occasions (once for my aunt's wedding, and then for my cousin's burial) I used to think that much of what goes on in the name of religion is childish humbug and priestly obscurantism. I used to be a strong champion of the motto Let A Thousand Flowers Bloom, and me and my mates believed that we should all celebrate Plurality instead of getting stuck up inside the suffocating attics of the religious mind. Unlike those who were dogmatically ensnared in all sorts of spiritual mumbo-jumbo, I was happy to know that I was free to enjoy my distinctiveness, my independence, and my autonomy, and to mould myself in any way I chose to.
One evening, however, when I was returning from the village pub at 11 in the night, I saw one of my mates repeatedly kick a black dog just beside the pavement for no apparent reason. I cannot explain clearly what happened to me at that moment but I think that I cracked up from within. Everything seemed to be whirling around me, and for the first time in my life the utter fragility, finitude, and frailty of my earthly existence became luminous to me in one sudden flash. I realised how deeply inter-dependent we are on one another, how much of a gift our existence is, and what a precarious life we lead as we move through this world.
Six months later, I embraced Islam at a mosque in East London and I have been a practising Muslim since then. My friends, some of whom I was very close to earlier, have now suddenly rejected me, but I really do not understand why they have turned their backs on me. If their slogan truly is Let A Thousand Flowers Bloom is not Islam one of these flowers too, and should it not therefore be allowed to bloom as well in their garden? Why should their secularised views be allowed to flourish more than my practice of Islam, if all these flowers are on par with one another as they are otherwise fond of declaring in public? True, after I have become a Muslim, I do not go any longer to their pubs, but so do they never come to my mosques. Why should I be branded as narrow-minded for not entering their pub when, from my viewpoint, they are equally so in refusing to enter my mosque? Why should I be denounced as intolerant for not accepting their claim that life is meaningless when, from my perspective, they are equally so in refusing even to consider for a moment my view that our life becomes meaningful within a context of responding to Allah's transcendent Will?
I have been informed by a friend that you have a rather delicate way of approaching (and exposing) these ironies of our multi-cultural existence, and I thought that you would publicise my adversity through your blog. I have just one question for your readers : how have we reached that stage of civilisation in which a life of trying not to believe in anything is regarded as more fashionable than a life in which an individual is passionately committed to one set of beliefs and practices that gives value, coherence, shape, and meaning to her existence?
Your brother,
Mohammed Aslam Beg (earlier John Ngugi)

Thursday, March 10, 2005

On The Notion Of Liberation Movements

A study of some of the greatest 'liberation movements' that have shaken the world reveals that human beings caught up in their cataclysmic vortices divide themselves, willingly or unwillingly, into at least three groups whom I shall call, with a little bit of caricature, The Give-me-blood revolutionary, The Trojan-horse revolutionary, and The Don't-give-a-damn revolutionary.
(a) The Give-me-blood revolutionary believes in a form of violent direct action that will meet head-on and topple the oppressive structures maintained and legitimised by those who are entrenched in positions of power. It divides the world into two vast swathes, one represented by the noble and valiant forces of Light (which includes them, and them alone), and the other which encompasses the demoniac denizens of Darkness, their sworn foes. No fraternizing with the enemy is to be allowed on any account, and any such activity is in fact punishable by immediate death.
(b) The Trojan-horse revolutionary is in some ways an even more sinister figure for she insinuates herself into the positions that are held by the elite without ever revealing to them her true identity. She digests the same food that they eat, utters the same words that they speak, breathes the same air that they gulp in, and in this very process she establishes herself more and more firmly into their world. But she grounds herself in their milieu not as a permanent resident, but as a time-bomb slowly ticking away, for she is ever on the look-out for chinks in their armour which are clearly manifest to her from her Trojan-horse position. In other words, she attempts to dismantle from the within the system that she opposes by striking at its weakest zones.
(c) The Don't-give-a-damn revolutionary is quite unruffled by all this nonsense going on around her, and she calls a plague upon both the above houses and retreats to the tranquil Himalayas. However, I do not find this an interesting stance to take (except perhaps in the Indian summer that the British glorified), and I shall not talk much more about it here.
Let me now take three examples of such 'liberation movements', firstly, the Indian freedom struggle; secondly, the ongoing women's movements in different zones of the world; and thirdly, the great contemporary debates over America. Regarding the first example, it is clear that followers of Subash Chandra Bose belonged to the first category, and Nehru and his devotees were members of the second group. Moving on to the second example, those in the first category would claim that everything, including the notion of rationality itself, is so irretrievably and irrevocably tainted by masculinity that women have no other option but to retreat to a lost Atlantis of universal Sisterhood, but those in the second argue that women must appropriate precisely those concepts that have become fetishised as male to beat men at their own game by exposing the inner contradictions of their hegemonic claims. Finally, with respect to the third example, the first type of revolutionary believes that there exists some reified entity called 'America' floating in the blue skies above her at which she can take random pot-shots and everything will become beautiful at one stroke, while the second behaves as a crafty Trojan horse and utilises Microsoft Word, Netscape Internet, New York publishing houses, Google Blogger, and CNN television, the very symbols of a much-hated America, to circulate anti-American oppositional and resistant thought among people in different locations.

Wednesday, March 09, 2005

The Transparent Ironist Goes Ethnic

Here is my up-to-date version, or remix, if you like, of Bob Dylan's ballad, 'How Many Times...?'

How many books must a man pretend to understand
Before he can be sold as intellectual?
Yes, 'n' how many diets must a woman survive
Before she can be bought as sexual?

How many weeks must you change your jeans labels
Before you can be appreciated as fashionable?
Yes, 'n' how many stones must you throw at Starbucks
To salve your conscience for Africa's miserable?

The answer, my friend, does not blow in the wind
The dead wind speaks to us no more
All we have in this darkness are flickering lights
Intimations of a land on the distant shore.


How many blasphemies must an atheist utter
Before he is acknowledged as really academic?
Yes, 'n' how many denunciations must the pious throw
Before they are certified as truly salvific?

How many CDs of the latest RnB must you buy
Until you are endorsed as firmly progressive?
Yes, 'n' how many Mozart concerts must you avoid
To prove that classical music is definitively regressive?

The answer, my friend, does not blow in the wind
The dead wind speaks to us no more
All we have in this darkness are flickering lights
Intimations of a land on the distant shore.


How many evenings must you shut yourself in your room
To establish the supremacy of your personal freedom?
Yes, 'n' how many cigarettes must you smoke with your coffee
To relieve yourself from the subsequent boredom?

How long must you grow your polished hair
To manifest your deep seething anarchy?
Yes, 'n' how often must you retreat to the jacuzzi
To escape from your unspoken hidden agony?

The answer, my friend, does not blow in the wind
The dead wind speaks to us no more
All we have in this darkness are flickering lights
Intimations of a land on the distant shore.


How many politically-correct terms must you master
Before nobody can brand you a bloody racist?
Yes, 'n' how many slurs must you cast upon America
Until you are ratified as a true-blood Maoist?

How many times must you declare that Truth is dead
Before you are praised as sophisticated?
Yes, 'n' how many times must you play with your words
Before you are celebrated as educated?

The answer, my friend, does not blow in the wind
The dead wind speaks to us no more
All we have in this darkness are flickering lights
Intimations of a land on the distant shore
.

How many sessions of yoga must you patiently endure
Before everyone recognises you as spiritual?
Yes, 'n' how many religions must you damn as superstitious
Before your friends welcome you as liberal?

How many times must you scream on a megaphone
That individual choice is the highest euphoria?
Yes, 'n' how many times must you contradict yourself
Until you go ahead and legalise euthanasia?

The answer, my friend, does not blow in the wind
The dead wind speaks to us no more
All we have in this darkness are flickering lights
Intimations of a land on the distant shore.




Tuesday, March 08, 2005

The Autobiography Of The Transparent Ironist : Chapter 2 Posted by Hello
(Special Issue For International Woman's Day, March 8)



(This is Chapter 2 of my autobiography My Experiments With Irony; once again, my earlier caveats about the term 'autobiography' hold. (See my introduction to Chapter 1 below.))
I am blessed with a certain gift that many of my friends only dream of (or, more commonly, dispute its existence) : the gift of withdrawing into myself like a tortoise retreating into its shell and looking back into my past lives. Therefore, unlike them who often do not know why they think and believe what they do, I am aware, only too painfully, where my beliefs and actions ultimately spring from, the dark but not unforgotten recesses of my strange past.
I clearly remember one of these past lives of mine : I was then living in British-occupied India in the stormy decade of the 1880s when the whole country was being turned upside-down by the White Man. I belonged to a family that came from a long line of pandits, scholars who read the sacred scriptures in Sanskrit and passed them down to the next generation. It was around that time, however, that the British government passed a regulation that more and more of the natives should be made to study English instead, and that funding to the vernacular schools was to be withdrawn. Our family lived in Malda, the land of the evergreen mango trees, and the officer posted there was a young man called Nathaniel Cornwallis, a stickler for perfection, who took his service to his King and Country extremely seriously.
He came to our house one morning and ordered my mother that I was to be taken away to Calcutta where I would be given a proper English education at the Scottish Church College there. She pleaded with him that I was her only son and that he should go to the family of someone with more children, only to receive the reply that I was being specially chosen since I came from a family of Sanskrit scholars. The argument was abruptly concluded with the infuriated Cornwallis calling in his men, and I was briskly dragged away from her into his coach, smelling beautifully of some faint perfume. I looked back at my old house and saw my mother standing forlorn at the withered gate, two steady streams of cold tears slowly flowing down her emaciated cheeks.
Thus I began a new life in Calcutta : I learnt the English alphabet, and began to hear strange names that I could not initially even pronounce, Macaulay, Keats, Byron, Dickens, Eliot, and Tennyson. Every morning I would wake up and repeat to myself with the rising sun some of the great sayings of the Upanisads, and in particular one of these tat tvam asi would reverberate inside my mind the whole day.
One morning, my mother came to see me when I was in Cornwallis' office explaining to him some principles from the Dharma-Sastras, the ancient Hindu law-books. Cornwallis immediately stiffened when he saw her enter his office, and exclaimed that I was now no longer her son, I was the son of the British Empire. Every mother, he explained, must learn to make sacrifices so that the Majesty of the Great Mother, Queen Victoria, may spread throughout the world. My mother replied that she did not wish to take me away from him, but wanted to talk to me for a few minutes. We talked in fact for a long time about what had been happening in my absence in my village; my family had been evicted from its ancestral home; the local crafts were dying out; and millions were starving to death on the streets.
And before she left, my mother told me : 'Son, learn this language that they call Angrezi thoroughly. Learn it so well that when you compose an essay or a poem in it no Englishman shall ever know that it has actually come from the pen of a native. And yet, my son, learn it not simply in order to enjoy it, but also to use it like a weapon against the Englishman. Read all their books thoroughly one by one, and when you have absorbed what they say, turn these books against the Englishman.' That was my mother's parting advice to me on that cold December morning. I never saw her again; I received a note from my village three weeks later informing me that she had peacefully died in her sleep.
As for myself, I went on to master not only the language, but also the poetry, the novels, the history, and the philosophy of the Englishman. It was then that I realised that I had come to possess a unique power : English was not just a language anymore, it had also become a political weapon of defiance and resistance. Through English, I learnt about liberty, fraternity, freedom, and equality and all the great values that people in Europe were fighting and dying for. Indeed, through my mastery of English, I had become like a Trojan horse that had secretly invaded the seemingly impenetrable fortress of the British Empire, learnt all its secrets inside out, found out all of its weakest links, and was now waiting to launch a full-fledged attack on it from the within. I was now truly a son of the British Empire, but what a son I had become!
By the time I was a dying man, I was happy to see that more and more of my countrymen were learning English, and were making themselves aware of the inner contradictions of an Empire that claimed, on the one hand, to be based on the noble ideal of Humanity and was perpetuated, on the other hand, through savage brutalities inflicted daily on the natives. I died in the year 1920 just as Mahatma Gandhi was starting one of the greatest mass movements that would shake the British Empire to its very roots, an Empire whose devoted son I have always remained. And yes, I have also always remained a loving son of my dear mother whose pain at her separation from her only child I would never forget. Indeed, if there is one transparent truth that I realised in that past-life of mine, one transparent truth that I do not wish to forget in any future-life of mine, it is this : the greatest monuments of so-called human civilisation are raised on the inhuman misery of billions of silently-suffering women.

Monday, March 07, 2005

Karl Marx's mother once wrote this about her son : 'If my son Karl had tried to earn some capital instead of writing a book about it, things would have been much better'. Do you agree with her?
The Autobiography Of The Transparent Ironist : Chapter 1 Posted by Hello





The following is Chapter 1 of the autobiography of The Transparent Ironist to be published in a serialised form in this blog as My Experiments With Irony. To circumvent a possible misunderstanding over what he is trying to do here, the Ironist wishes to make it clear to his readers at the outset how he is going to deploy the term 'autobiography'. He understands this term to mean primarily not a sequential recounting of historical data (this is something only journalists do) but an imaginative narrative of possible events, a narrative which seeks to highlight some of the ironies of our day-to-day existence in the present. In this chapter, for example, he shall freely mix 'fact' with 'fantasy', the 'fact' of the uneasy (though politically-incorrect) fascination that he has for British India with the 'fantasy' of his being born in London.


I was born in London in the 1960s just as the immigrants were beginning to pour into Britain from the different ends of the erstwhile Empire. I went to school in an area with a significant proportion of Indians and Pakistanis, and there I established a life-long friendship with an Indian friend called Homi Bhaskar. Through this association, I had already developed an interest in the history of the Indian subcontinent when I was in high school, and later when it was time for me to go to University I decided to take up South Asian studies at Cambridge. After Cambridge, I joined an international firm dealing in telecommunications in London, though I still tried my best, partly with the help of Homi, to keep up with the latest literature on Indian affairs.
It was in the middle of the sultry summer of 1998 that I had a terrible dream that would shake me to the bottomest depths of my being. I dreamt that I was in the heartlands of colonial India as a young colonel in His Majesty's Army in the dusty plains of the Oudh. I had been ordered by my superior Sir Havelock Nicholson to take a company of my men and march into the neighbouring village from where we had received some reports of the natives rebelling against the local officers. On the way to the village, however, I heard a series of earth-shattering screams pouring out into the sky from a thick jungle, and I directed three of my junior officers to investigate the matter. They promptly moved into the jungle and returned to tell me that it was a deranged native woman who was shrieking in some strange fit of agony. I went in along with them, and saw a woman with dishevelled hair clawing the air around her with her fingers while two men were trying to beat with her a stick. I jumped down from my horse and was about to move towards her when my junior officer Archdale Ferguson warned me that she was possessed and that I should not interfere with the men who were trying to cure her. I hesitated for a few moments and stood motionless watching her, but soon I could not endure her tormented screeches anymore. I slowly walked towards her, and she suddenly charged at me like a wild beast and nearly chopped off the middle finger on my right hand with her savage and brilliantly-white teeth.
I woke up in a cold sweat, and one glance at the morning sun told me that I was already very late for work. I rushed downstairs, forced myself into the Tube, and reached my office just as my secretary was laying out some yellow papers on my green desk.
'You have to sign these papers before the meeting at 11.'
'What papers?'
'Surely you haven't forgotten? We are out-sourcing half of our business to India next month, and those are the papers you need to sign.'
She gave me a shining silver pen, and I struggled with it to put my signatures below the dotted lines.
'Is something wrong with your middle finger? Your signature is so shaky today.'
'My middle finger? No, nothing, nothing. I mean nothing is wrong with it.'
Later that evening when I returned home, I took out a white sheet of paper and tried my signature on it. My secretary was right : there was indeed something wrong with my middle finger that was preventing me from signing my name the way I was used to doing. Indeed, I have never been able to sign it properly since that midsummer night's dream in 1998. Once I even thought of going to my doctor about it. But what would I tell my doctor : that a native woman from colonial India had bitten my middle finger and I could not sign my name properly as a consequence?

Sunday, March 06, 2005

The Transparent Ironist Replies To Rudyard Kipling, Esq.
The 'Indo-British' poet Rudyard Kipling (1865 - 1936), born in Bombay, was (arguably) a defender of British imperialism in India, and he coined the phrase 'The White Man's Burden'. He was awarded the Nobel Prize in 1907, and is remembered, among other things, as the writer of The Ballad of East and West, the beginning lines of which are as follows :
Oh, East is East, and West is West, and never the twain shall meet,
Till Earth and Sky stand presently at God's great Judgment Seat;
But there is neither East nor West, Border, nor Breed, nor Birth,
When two strong men stand face to face,
tho' they come from the ends of the earth!
Many years later in 2005, the Transparent Ironist, himself a thoroughly Anglicized native now living in the UK, makes the following riposte to Mr Kipling, Esq. :
Oh, East is West, and West is East, and the twain have already met
Their destinies now shaped by bloody encounters of love and hate
But there is still East and West, Nation, Race, and Gender
When two horizons meet under the placid blue skies
Their hidden frictions can still tear the world asunder!
 
Free FAQ Database from Bravenet Free FAQ Database from Bravenet.com
The WeatherPixie