The Anarchy of Thought

Charity begins at home. Perhaps. But then so does the long revolution against the Establishment.

Friday, February 18, 2005

Amaro Porano Jaha Chay Posted by Hello
One of the ironies in my life (and this one has a tragic ring about it) is the fact that I have lost my childhood fluency in Bengali, a language that I believe is infinitely more beautiful, more melodious, more playful, and more delightful than English which can get rather drab at times and which is the language that now permeates my entire being. Indeed, I like to divide the world not along national lines but along linguistic ones so that I instinctively feel more comfortable in the presence of a Bengali-speaker from Dhaka, London, or New York than a Hindi-speaker from Patna, an Assamese-speaker from Tezpur (Assamese and not Bengali, by the way, is my native tongue), or a Tamil-speaker from Chennai. Indeed, if I were to meet a Bengali-speaker in Islamabad, I would willingly fraternize with the enemy. Does this make me a linguistic chauvinist? Yes, and No. No, because this is not to say that Bengali-speakers have by virtue of their speaking Bengali attained the pinnacle of Humanity (whatever that is). But Yes, because only native speakers of Bengali know what those who cannot read Rabindranath Tagore in the original are missing out in life. (Still not satisfied? You insist that when two Bengalis meet each other, they should speak not in Bengali but in English? My!My!My! Is that not another disguised form of linguistic chauvinism? One in favour of English?)

2 Comments:

  • At 18.2.05, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    'pran o bhoriye trisha horiye more aro aro aro daao pran , tobo bhubone tobo bhobone more aro aro aro daao sthaan ... aro bedona aro ... provu daao mroe aro chetona ... dwaro chhutaye badha tutaye mroe koro tran mroe koro tran ... aro prem e prem e mor 'ami' dube jaak neme ... sudhadhare aponaare more koro ... mroe koro daan ' plz forgive me for some missing words which i've already forgotten ... thnx n bye .

     
  • At 25.2.05, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Have you noticed how sometimes it is quite a different experience to know someone in Bengali than to know someone in English? I wonder if our very personalities, our perspectives and dreams change with the switch from one tongue to another.
    Do you 'Jodi Taare' still?

     

Post a Comment

<< Home

 
Free FAQ Database from Bravenet Free FAQ Database from Bravenet.com
The WeatherPixie